By Rosalyn Kemp, CFP® | Founder, Chestnut Beach Wealth
Ask a financial professional almost any question, and you’ll probably hear some version of “Well, it depends.” That’s usually the correct answer. It’s also maddening when you just want to know what to do. So I wasn’t surprised that 18% of Americans who sought financial guidance used AI last year, according to a 2026 Gallup survey conducted with Edward Jones.[1] I expected the number to be higher.
Finance sounds impossible to sort out without an advanced degree. The vocabulary is strange, the rules keep changing, and a choice you make at 30 can still be costing you at 60. I’ve spent endless hours learning this stuff, and I pick up something new almost every day. Most people are experts in something else, but they still have to pick their 401(k) investments, file their taxes, and decide whether they can afford the house.

Even an advanced degree might not be enough. My husband has an MD and is honest enough to tell me when I don’t make any sense. When I talk about the economy or financial markets, he’ll sometimes stop me and say, “I have no idea what you just said.”
Recently, on a car ride home, he asked me to explain the Federal Reserve and the yield curve as if we were fourth graders. It took me the entire ride. I eventually came up with an analogy involving baseball cards and a card shop. I’m pretty sure AI would have done a better job.
AI lets you ask questions, explore unfamiliar concepts, and learn at your own pace. This is a good thing. I love when a client comes to me understanding the difference between account types or knowing to ask specific questions about new tax rules. The more clients understand, the more engaged they are in their decisions and the more likely they are to stick with our plan.
I don’t think it’s controversial to say schools aren’t doing a great job teaching financial literacy, so I’m glad young adults are using AI to build their financial knowledge. In the same Gallup survey, about a quarter of Gen Z and millennial adults who sought financial guidance had used AI, compared with just 7% of baby boomers.[1] That matters because Morningstar estimates that about 45% of U.S. households risk running short of money in retirement.[2] AI can help people build budgets, understand workplace retirement plans, automate savings, and develop better financial habits before small decisions turn into expensive mistakes.
Do you remember the benefits package from your first job? I barely understood mine. My health care plan after college was try not to get hit by a bus because I didn’t check the right box before the enrollment window closed.
Today’s graduates can upload their benefits brochure into AI and ask for help understanding their options. It can walk them through setting a retirement contribution rate, capturing the employer match, and setting aside money for an emergency fund. Those early steps can make a meaningful difference over time, especially with the power of compounding.
But as your finances grow, knowing the basics isn’t always enough to decide what to do next.
Financial decisions rarely happen in isolation. The right choice depends not only on how much money you have, but also on what you need it to do, when you need it, who it supports, and how it fits with the rest of your financial life. A decision that makes sense for one person may be wrong for another because of differences in taxes, family obligations, retirement timing, or future spending needs.
To see how AI handles that complexity, I pretended I had received a year-end bonus and typed into ChatGPT, “I just got a year-end bonus! How should I invest it?”
First, it congratulated me, of course. My ever-steady cheerleader. Then it asked about my tax withholding and my stability bucket, part of the three-bucket investment strategy I’ve taught it. It suggested maximizing tax-advantaged accounts, making a charitable contribution through a donor-advised fund, investing a lump sum in a taxable account, and spending some of the money. It even reminded me to check with my CPA before the December deadlines.
Good job, ChatGPT. The suggestions were reasonable, but I got a fairly long list of options and no clear recommendation. It might as well have started with, “Well, Roz, it depends.”
And that’s the point. The best use of a bonus depends on your cash reserves, upcoming expenses, tax situation, and competing priorities. AI can help organize the questions, but it needs the right information to give a useful answer.
That distinction helps explain why people may be comfortable using AI to learn without being ready to rely on it for consequential decisions. In the Gallup survey, 79% of adults expressed at least some confidence in financial advisors’ expertise in managing money, compared with 27% for AI tools.[1] There is both real and perceived value in earning your stripes empirically, rather than learning about it from a textbook or observing from a distance.
I spent the first couple of decades of my career trading in capital markets, so I understand the difference between knowing risk intellectually (yes, with Greek letters) and experiencing it emotionally. When markets fall, selling can feel like the safest move. Get me out! But that instinct can undermine a long-term plan. We make long-term plans, but we experience markets in the short term. That mismatch is what makes investing so hard.
While I think AI could explain the yield curve to a fourth grader, I don’t think it can reliably help people manage their emotions when markets stop making sense to them. AI can explain what a bear market is, run the numbers on a Roth conversion, or lay out five ways to use a bonus, but it doesn’t know if you lost sleep the last time the market fell. Most people don’t realize how much that detail matters.
AI can help you understand money and the complex rules we’ve created around it. That’s especially valuable when you’re just starting out, but as life gets more complicated, the hardest financial problems stop being math problems. They become human ones: knowing what you value, facing what scares you, and making choices that serve the life you want, even when it’s hard. If AI can learn to help with those challenges, it will be a remarkable partner. Until then, that’s what a good advisor is for.
About the Author
Rosalyn Kemp, CFP®, founded Chestnut Beach Wealth, an independent, fee-only fiduciary wealth planning firm based in Wilmette, Illinois. After 26 years in institutional capital markets, she helps individuals and families navigate financial complexity through coordinated investment, tax, and financial planning.
Sources
[1] Gallup and Edward Jones, “Where Americans and Canadians Turn for Financial Guidance,” August 5, 2026. Survey of U.S. adults on the use of and confidence in financial guidance sources.
[2] Morningstar Center for Retirement and Policy Studies, “Morningstar Retirement Launches New Morningstar Model of US Retirement Outcomes,” July 2024.
[3] Jeffrey Ptak, Mind the Gap 2026, Morningstar, August 2026. Analysis of the difference between investor returns and fund returns over the 10 years through December 2025.




