Your AI finance app can tell when you’re struggling. Will it help you, or cash in?

By Amanda di Medici, Founder and Chief Executive, Yenom

I’ve sat with a lot of people who are behind on their bills. It’s been my job. Again and again, they open the banking app, look at the balance and close it. They haven’t given up. They just can’t face it.

That exact moment is the real test of an AI finance app. Most are built for someone with the time and headspace to act on what they see. People under financial stress have neither time nor headspace.

Why AI finance apps must protect users at their worst moment

An app that can see your balance can see when you’re struggling. Research published in Science found that money worries use up mental capacity, leaving less for everything else. So a refinance or debt consolidation offer that arrives at that point reaches someone less able to weigh it up.

Amanda di Medici

In the US, Credit Karma says it is typically paid by the lender or bank when a member signs up for a product it recommends. Its Debt Assistant builds a debt consolidation plan that, in Credit Karma’s words, is “paired with loan offers”. There is nothing improper in that model, but it raises a fair question: what does an app that is paid when you borrow say to someone who shouldn’t?

In Australia, WeMoney promotes itself as a way to pay off debt faster. Its credit guide says it receives upfront and trail commission from lenders when a member takes out a loan through its service, and lists 11 lenders on its panel. To its credit, WeMoney’s own guidance says that for someone who can’t meet their repayments, a new loan is “rarely the right first move”, and points them to their lenders’ hardship teams and the National Debt Helpline. The test for any app is whether its AI gives that same advice at the moment it counts.

Cleo, an AI money coach for Gen Z in the UK and US, now remembers a user’s goals, habits and financial history, and also offers cash advances. In 2025 it agreed to pay US$17 million to settle FTC allegations that it misled users about advance amounts and fees. Cleo neither admitted nor denied the allegations.

Lesson one: If an AI knows someone is struggling, that knowledge should protect and help them, not be used to sell to them.

Why engagement-driven finance apps miss stressed users

Most apps assume people check them regularly. Financially stressed people often don’t.

A National Bureau of Economic Research working paper found that people check their accounts more after payday, and less once they slip into overdraft. In Australia, a poll of 1,000 people by comparison site Compare Club in October 2026 found 62.7% had avoided checking their bank balance for fear of what they’d find.

An app that waits to be opened misses people when they most need help, and every extra alert asks for attention a money worry has already used up.

Better to let the app do the work. Sort the transactions. Flag the bill due before payday. Show users the one thing worth knowing. Rocket Money’s AI assistant, Rowan, watches accounts, texts users about price hikes and can cancel subscriptions for them. But it costs US$15 a month. No cash-strapped person is going to pay that.

Lesson two: Nudge with useful information and simple advice people can act on, keep education relevant and ongoing — and make the app free, at least for people on lower incomes. You already know exactly how much money they have.

Making personal finance apps a safe space

In Beyond Blue’s 2026 national survey of more than 5,000 Australian adults, 47% said cost-of-living pressures were hurting their mental health, and money was the most common source of personal distress, ahead of work and relationships. And that’s before you add apps with alarming red warnings, streaks to break and language that suggests failure.

Cleo has a “roast mode” that pokes fun at a user’s spending. That might be funny if you’re in a financial sweet spot. Not if you’re a week short on rent. Luckily, there’s a ‘hype’ mode too.

A new idea here, what about an anonymous forum built in? Money secrecy is common — 48.3% of people in the Compare Club poll had lied to a partner or family member about money. A forum may help people realise they aren’t alone. Research on peer groups for people in debt suggests that seeing others in the same position can ease the shame that keeps people hiding it.

There also has to be a way to reach an actual, live person. The US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has warned that chatbots can trap customers in “doom loops” with no route to a human. That person needn’t work for the app — free financial counselling exists through the National Debt Helpline in Australia, MoneyHelper in the UK and non-profit credit counselling agencies in the US. An app that spots distress should point people there.

Lesson three: Realise that some, possibly most, of your users are financially stressed and need genuine help. Give that help, without strings or agendas.

What better AI finance app design looks like

Carlin, Olafsson and Pagel studied Meniga, an Icelandic app that brings a person’s everyday, savings and credit card accounts into one view. After it launched on mobile in 2014, insufficient-funds fees among people using it fell by about 38% within two years. The researchers put the drop down mainly to users avoiding mistakes because the information was easier to reach.

I’d put three questions to anyone building an AI finance app. Does it protect people at their weakest moment, or try to sell to them for its own financial gain? Does it give useful, timely help that people on low incomes can afford? And when someone is struggling, does it get them to a real person, no strings attached?

Those questions should be the baseline for anyone building in this space.

About the author:

Amanda di Medici is Founder and Chief Executive of Yenom, an Australian workplace financial wellbeing organisation that holds no financial services licence, sells no financial products and takes no commissions. Yenom is also building a financial wellbeing app. A financial literacy educator with qualifications in law, finance and adult education, Amanda has spent more than 20 years working with people in financial stress, including as a financial counsellor.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest Articles